Holding Privilege is an educational game that designers and design students can use as a tool to talk about and reflect on their own relationships to power, identity and privilege. The game offers an opportunity for players to address the diversity gap in the design field and in higher education. Holding Privilege is intended be used in a learning space such as a classroom or workshop and guided by a facilitator or educator. 

PROJECT

OVERVIEW

There is a deep divide in access, representation and power in the design world. If we can agree that design is in everything and that everything is designed, then who designs really matters. The people and the voices missing, and those most impacted by the choices of designers matter too.  

 

It is crucial that designers interrogate their own privileges, reactions, biases and blind spots so that we can better understand our power and work towards greater equity and inclusion for the world. In the social design space, it is even more crucial that young designers understand themselves before going into communities or addressing social issues through their work.

CHALLENGE

Audit Tool

PHASE 2 

SYNTHESIZING DATA 

We designed & facilitated (2) Sensemaking workshops.

 

Using the data collected by CJWG, members had the opportunity to analyze the results by identifying gaps and needs, make recommendations and explore localized solutions to address urgent needs for next year’s summer roll out of cooling centers. 

SENSEMAKING WITH COMMUNITY

APPROACH

Audit Tool

 

Climate Justice Working Group (CJWG)  members used a paper survey tool to collect observational and ethnographic data on:

 

​1. the state of the facilities

2. user experiences 

3. staff knowledge 

PHASE 1 

CO DESIGNING THE AUDIT TOOL 

We co-designed the audit tool with CJWG to be used to collect data from functioning cooling centers during the summer months of 2019. When designing the survey, we considered varying degrees of interaction needed for members to gather information on site. The activities ranged from traditional one-on-one interviews, user journey mapping and surveys, allowing community members to be design researchers in their own right.

COMMUNITY MEMBERS

AS DESIGN RESEARCHERS

PARTNER 

DSI Advisors Maggie Breslin & Asi Burak

Project selected for Fast Track Independent Study at SVA 

ROLE

DESIGN RESEARCH, VISUAL & UX DESIGN

PROJECT DURATION

 2019 | 4 MONTHS

TEAM

 LORENA ESTRELLA

A GAME ABOUT POWER & PRIVILEGE

Open site navigation

SENSEMAKING WORKSHOP 1

At the start of the workshop members were encouraged to view each data visualization poster containing an overview of the data.

Separating into smaller teams, the members sifted through the qualitative data points, pulling out key information then synthesized the data to form clusters of themes and patterns. Having each group share out their themes collectively enabled all members to see the results and commonalities.

SENSEMAKING WORKSHOP 2

 

We used the prototyping process to get the community members comfortable with testing out their ideas. We guided them through the process of framing problems and using “How Might We” statements which led to brainstorming of ideas and potential solutions. We introduced the use of prototyping tools such as  storyboarding, sketching & the use of roleplaying for members to create representations of their solutions. 

Data Visualization

 

Using the audit tool, CJWG conducted audits of (5) Cooling Centers in Northern Manhattan neighborhoods; West Harlem, Central Harlem, Inwood, East Harlem & Washington Heights. Data Visualization posters were then designed using the data collected. 

The Cooling Center audit project resulted in the identification of some chronic malfunctions and inadequacies among the sites. The CJWG identified many levers for improvement that would make the program more impactful. 

When the community itself gathers data & makes sense of issues in their own neighborhood by filtering it through their own lived experience as Harlem residents dealing with issues that affect them directly, it allows for data analysis and policy making to be inclusive, transparent & impactful. 

OUTCOMES